Skip to content   Skip to footer navigation 

How to choose the best granola

How is granola different from muesli? Is it healthy? Which ones are the most nutritious? We answer a cluster of questions.

Granola in a bowl
Last updated: 30 June 2023
Fact-checked

Fact-checked

Checked for accuracy by our qualified fact-checkers, verifiers and subject experts. Find out more about fact-checking at CHOICE.

Granola, muesli's fancier and generally more expensive cousin, usually contains toasted oats, fruit and nuts, with the addition of a sugar to help the oats and other ingredients cluster together. The result?  An awesome-tasting, crunchy toasted cereal. 

We analysed more than 70 breakfast cereals labelled with the word "granola" or "cluster", to see which ones came out better nutritionally.

Top scoring granola

To find this selection, we assessed the granola products on their Health Star Rating (HSR) and the estimated added sugar content. Three of these products have less than four grams (one teaspoon) of estimated added sugar per serve.

Breakfast Cereals GR-47-1

Blue Frog Keto Almond, Peanut & Raspberry Cereal

  • HSR: 5
  • Estimated added sugar: 0g per 100g
  • Fibre: 17.9g per 100g
  • Claims on pack: 88% nuts and seeds, 1g sugar per serve, gluten-free
GR-71-1

Carman's Low Sugar Granola Raspberry and Coconut 450g

  • HSR: 5
  • Estimated added sugar: 4.8g per 100g
  • Fibre: 17.2g per 100g
  • Price: $1.53 per 100g
  • Claims on pack: Excellent source of fibre, no artificial colours or flavours, low sugar, less than 3g sugar per serve, prebiotic fibre, suitable for a vegan diet
GRB 1 of 2

Jordan's Low Sugar Granola Almond Hazelnut 500g

  • HSR: 4.5
  • Estimated added sugar: 0g per 100g
  • Fibre: 7.9g per 100g
  • Price: $1.70 per 100g
  • Claims on pack: Less than 5% sugar (total sugar), no artificial colours or preservatives, suitable for vegetarians, whole grain oats
Breakfast Cereals GR-24-1

Jordan's Granola Low Sugar Cherry Almond 500g

  • HSR: 4.5
  • Estimated added sugar: 0.7g per 100g,
  • Fibre: 7.4g per 100g
  • Price: $1.70 per 100g
  • Claims on pack: Less than 5% sugar (total sugar), low sugar, no artificial colours or preservatives, wholegrain oats, suitable for vegetarians

Is granola good for you?

Sugar

Granola can be high in sugar because it is necessary to help form clusters of cereal. However, in our review of 300+ cereals that include categories such as muesli, oats, kids' cereals and flakes, it was the granola category that had the most claims regarding sugar, with 21 products bearing a claim about low or reduced sugar.

Wholegrains

The use of wholegrains such as rolled oats and barley in some granolas means they have the benefit of containing fibre, and at least 26 different nutrients including carbohydrates, protein, minerals and a variety of phytonutrients. Consuming wholegrains is also shown to reduce inflammation-related conditions.

Fat

If the granola has been toasted with oils it may have a higher fat content than granola that's been dry-toasted. So if you're watching your kilojoule intake, look for those without added oils.

Which is better: Granola or muesli?

If you're stuck between the choice of buying granola or muesli for breakfast, on average muesli will be the healthier choice. 

In our review, muesli has an average HSR of 4, with an average estimated added sugar content of 3.6g per 100g. Granola products had an average HSR of 3.6, with an average estimated added sugar content of 13g per 100g. 

If you're looking to save money, then muesli again is the better choice. The muesli products in our review averaged $1.62 per 100g, compared with $2.24 per 100g on average for granola.

How we tested granola

The granola label information was collected, and where Health Star Ratings weren't available on pack we estimated them, using estimates for fruit and nut content where necessary. Estimates of added sugar per 100g were sourced from the George Institutes Food Switch Team.

To find the top rating granola products, we ranked them by Health Star Rating and added sugars per 100g as listed by the George Institutes Food Switch App

We care about accuracy. See something that's not quite right in this article? Let us know or read more about fact-checking at CHOICE.

Stock images: Getty, unless otherwise stated.